Wednesday, January 09, 2008

Fuel saver - snake oil or not ?

The SMH has an article about a new device that can reputedly reduce petrol consumption and greenhouse emissions by 20% from a company called Moletech. Their marketing campaign at the CES show seems to have been very successful, getting the attention of sites like Engadget.

Unsurprisingly, to my cynical eyes, the article is very short on details about how this feat is achieved. While I'd like think we could get a significant boost to both improve fuel economy and lower emissions so easily, it does rather sound like snake oil, all protestations to the contrary. On the subject of miracle fuel saving technologies, what happened to high profile (last year) company Firepower ?
The retired founder of the Strathfield retail group is going global with his next big project – a fuel saver device that cuts weekly petrol costs by up to 20 per cent and significantly lowers greenhouse gas emissions.

Andrew Kelly, now chief executive officer of Moletech, says his patented Fuel Saver kit is easily installed in any fossil-fuelled vehicle and improves fuel efficiency by changing the properties of gasoline in the tank. No modifications to the original structure of the vehicle are required.

Many have tried and failed to produce a product capable of noticeably improving fuel efficiency and reducing toxic emissions, but Kelly insists he isn't selling snake oil.

According to an assessment of Fuel Saver by associate professor Peter Dingle, of the environmental science department at Australia's Murdoch University, the technology has been independently tested in Australia, China, USA and Taiwan with positive results.

"The test results show enhanced combustion leads to a 20 per cent increase in fuel efficiency, a significant and large decline in toxic hydrocarbons, nitrogen oxides and carbon monoxide, and a minimal 20 per cent decrease in greenhouse gases," Dr Dingle wrote. He concluded Fuel Saver demonstrated benefits for all car users and widespread installation would benefit Australians health, environment and economy.

For six cylinder or V8 vehicles a Fuel Saver kit costs $399, while a cheaper $299 kit is available for four cylinder cars. There are different versions of the product depending on whether the vehicle takes gasoline, diesel or LPG. ...

The Fuel Saver kit consists of four ceramic fuel "sensors" that are dropped into the gas tank and attached to the air cleaner and radiator hose.

In proof of concept testing, the California Environmental Engineering laboratory said its results verified with a high level of confidence the viability of Fuel Saver and indicated more dramatic improvements could be expected and achieved with time. "The device, as tested, provided results that are more dramatic than similar technologies previously evaluated," research director Joseph Jones wrote.

In a vehicle emissions test report conducted in October last year, Australia's Department of Transport and Regional Services found Fuel Saver led to "an increasing improvement in fuel economy and a reduction in vehicle tailpipe emissions. This included a significant reduction in greenhouse gases (28 per cent)," the report concluded.

8 comments:

  1. Anonymous4:12 PM

    Every time I hear a claim of 20% or so economy, I know immediately it is a snake oil. I was working in a research firm for a while, and one of my responsibilities was testing of such devices. Out of several dozens I tested, not a single one showed any noticeable improvement in economy.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous10:54 AM

    Gents, regardless of how good or not this Fuel Saver thing is Andrew Kelly has left Australia owing over $5m to mobile phone company Strathfield, which he was the founder of.
    The guy cant afford to pay them back and so has come up with Fuel Saver as a new business. I wouldn't do business with someone like that.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Do you have a reference (link) for that last bit of information ?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous12:55 AM

    Doctor Dingle runs a wellness centre that promotes "holistic" healing practices including hypnosis, naturopathy, detox and BrainGym!!!

    While this doesn't mean he isn't right about the Moletech device, it does raise the skeptical hackles a little.

    I hope this thing does work but I won't be spending money to test it.

    The claim at moletech that the device absorbs energy from its surroundings then emits it in a way that splits the fuel molecules just sounds - well - wrong, somehow. Magnet anyone?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hmmm... sounds tempting, but in my experience with add on devices and research on the web, I've found most are just snake oil. I'd love to find a product that delivers on it's promise.

    So far,the best advice I've experienced is to change my driving habits. These I'm posting on my blog. You can have a look at it at http://www.fuelsaver-solo.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  6. Anonymous5:32 AM

    Till you use Moletech in your car or truck you will never know!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Sounds like a recipe for disappointment to me...

    ReplyDelete
  8. Start withe the basics and buy fuel when it is at its weekly low, generally on a Tuesday afternoon.

    ReplyDelete